Guide

Understanding the NDAA Section 1286 List for Research Security

Research Security
Kharon team

Kharon Staff

·4 min

Section 1286

Collaborating with an institution on the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) Section 1286 List can cost a university its defense research funding. Congress has barred DoD from using fiscal year (FY) 2025 and 2026 funds for fundamental research that a university conducts in collaboration with a listed institution or its employees, and DoD's guidance states that, effective FY2026, the prohibition applies to any department funds.

FY2027 began Oct. 1, 2026, and Congress has not yet enacted the FY2027 NDAA. The Senate Armed Services Committee's version of the bill would extend the statutory prohibition to FY2027 funds if that provision becomes law. In the meantime, DoD's guidance still treats the prohibition as in effect, so a university that misses a listed collaborator in a proposal puts its eligibility for defense research awards at risk.

What is the NDAA Section 1286 List?

Section 1286 of the John S. McCain NDAA for Fiscal Year 2019, as amended, requires DoD to maintain a list of foreign institutions and foreign talent recruitment programs that it has determined pose a threat to U.S. national security. The current list, which DoD published July 23, 2026, names 130 universities, research institutes, and laboratories in China, Russia, and Iran.

Listing does not, on its own, prohibit collaboration. The funding restriction comes from separate provisions in the FY2025 and FY2026 NDAAs that apply to institutions on the list.


How Section 1286 Affects Research Funding

Section 238 of the FY2025 NDAA established the prohibition for FY2025 funds, and Section 215 of the FY2026 NDAA extended it to FY2026 funds. Under both, DoD may not use those funds to award a grant or contract to an institution of higher education for the specific purposes of conducting fundamental research in collaboration with a listed academic institution or its employees. The Assistant Secretary of Defense for Science and Technology may waive the prohibition on a case-by-case basis when a waiver serves U.S. national security interests.

DoD’s guidance goes further than the statute in two ways. The statute covers grants and contracts, while the guidance adds any other assistance to institutions of higher education. The guidance also covers research that uses equipment from a listed entity, not only research conducted in collaboration with one.

DoD has also used the list to audit universities directly, not only to screen individual award proposals. On Aug. 17, 2026, the department directed 30 U.S. academic institutions to review their academic, financial, and research collaborations with Section 1286 entities and with organizations associated with rebranded Confucius Institutes, and to report their findings and actions by Aug. 31, 2026. Confucius Institutes were educational partnerships between entities in China and U.S. host universities that offered Chinese language and culture programs; their number at U.S. schools fell from about 100 in 2019 to fewer than five by 2023. DoD's review extended to organizations that continue that work under new names, and on Oct. 23, 2026, the department designated Confucius Institutes a national security threat, according to an X post by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. On Oct. 19, 2026, DoD reported that all 30 institutions had mitigated the relationships it identified with entities on the July 2026 list, through more than 80 termination-related actions, and warned that institutions failing its research security standards would not receive taxpayer funding.


What Counts as Collaboration

The statutory definition of collaboration reaches beyond a formal partnership. It includes sharing facilities, resources, data, or technical know-how; financial or in-kind contributions toward a research product; sponsored research fellowships or visas; joint research agreements; and roles as consultants, advisers, or advisory board members.

For example, a proposed project that would share research data with an employee of a listed university may fall within the restriction even when that university is not a named institutional partner.


Which Universities Are on the Section 1286 List?

The list names 130 institutions in China, Russia, and Iran. Its July 23, 2026, update added Fudan University, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, and Shandong University, three of China’s most prominent civilian research universities. These additions extended the list beyond the military academies and defense-linked universities it has long included.

An analysis in the Kharon Brief examines the newly listed universities and their connections to China’s military modernization efforts.

What Research Security Offices Should Review

A Section 1286 review establishes where each collaborator on a proposed project is employed, since the restriction applies when that employer is a listed institution. A collaborator may appear in a proposal under a laboratory, department, or joint institute rather than a listed university’s name, and a documented employment relationship can bring that collaborator within the restriction even if the proposal names only an unlisted research unit.

A practical review covers:

  • Employment and appointments: Identify each collaborator’s current employer and, additional appointments, and then establish how each laboratory or institute relates to a listed institution.

  • Arrangements beyond agreements: Review shared data, equipment, funding, and advisory roles alongside formal research agreements, since the statutory definition of collaboration reaches all of them.

  • Disclosures: Check researchers’ disclosures against documented affiliations, because the Pentagon requires researchers to disclose affiliations with listed entities and activities related to foreign talent recruitment programs.

  • Changes over time: Reassess relationships whenever the list or a researcher’s affiliations change, and document how each potential restriction was resolved.

The DoD offices that award research funding, including the Army, Navy, Air Force, and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), review fundamental research proposals using the department’s 2026 decision matrix, issued March 9, 2026. The matrix treats collaboration with an institution on the Section 1286 List as prohibited, not as a risk that mitigation measures can address. A Kharon article on balancing collaboration and compliance in university research security explains how assessing foreign affiliations gives institutions the evidence to document their collaboration decisions.

Frequently asked questions

Does the Section 1286 funding restriction apply to FY2027 funds?

Not yet by statute. Sections 238 and 215 cover FY2025 and FY2026 funds, and Congress has not enacted the FY2027 NDAA. The Senate Armed Services Committee’s version would extend the prohibition to FY2027 funds. DoD’s guidance already applies the restriction to any department funds from FY2026 forward.

Does the funding restriction cover individual researchers?

Yes. The statutory definition of a covered entity includes any individual employed by a listed academic institution, so screening only the institution named in an agreement can miss a relevant connection.

Does the Section 1286 List prohibit all collaboration with listed institutions?

No. Sections 238 and 215 restrict DoD funds for fundamental research; they do not bar collaboration that other sources fund. DoD has warned, however, that collaborating with an individual affiliated with a listed entity may affect a researcher’s eligibility for federal funding. Export controls apply separately: parties on the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) Entity List carry license requirements whether or not they appear on the Section 1286 List.


Does the restriction apply to funding from other federal agencies, such as the National Science Foundation (NSF) or the National Institutes of Health (NIH)?

No. Sections 238 and 215 apply only to DoD funds. Other agencies impose their own research security requirements, including the CHIPS and Science Act’s prohibition on federally funded researchers participating in malign foreign talent recruitment programs.


What is the difference between the Section 1286 List and the Section 1260H List?

Section 1286 addresses foreign institutions and talent programs in the research security context. Section 1260H of the FY2021 NDAA identifies Chinese military companies. Kharon’s Section 1260H compliance guide explains the separate procurement restrictions tied to that list.

Assess Research Affiliations with Kharon

Often, the most challenging part of a Section 1286 review is establishing a collaborator’s affiliations, because an appointment at a listed university’s laboratory or joint institute often does not appear in the proposal itself. Kharon’s research security solutions, trusted by more than 50 leading research institutions worldwide, identify affiliations of concern involving foreign universities, research institutes, and companies.

Kharon’s data can show:

  • Researcher appointments: Current and past appointments that may tie a collaborator to a listed university, including through a laboratory or joint institute.

  • Institutional structure: How laboratories, departments, and joint institutes may relate to a parent institution on the Section 1286 List.

  • Defense and export control links: Connections between a listed institution and military end users or Entity List parties.

Kharon ClearView lets research security officers explore the affiliations Kharon has mapped around a researcher or institution and see the sourcing behind each one. GraphCast delivers Kharon’s data into the screening and research security systems institutions already use, including Digital Science’s Dimensions Research Security platform.

Explore Kharon’s solutions for universities and research institutions, including support for collaboration reviews and visiting scholar assessments.

Have more questions? Get in touch with us

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

1286 Rule Explained for Research Security | Kharon